Submitted work by JudithA

Analyzing Objects

Porcelain

Musket Ball

Smallpox

Nail

Reaper

Shirtwaist

Transistor

Coffee

Record

Tire

Dishwasher

Dress

Stereograph

Stone

Mail

Shoe

Question 1:
I am not sure if I was to give my definition or use my computer. So, I read several definitions. One says 'historical thinking is a set of critical literacy skills for evaluating and analyzing primary source documents to construct a meaningful account of the past" I would never have answered it that way. I would have said, "a way of understanding history by using objects"
Question 2:
For instance I had a Union Civil War Buff come to my History 11 class last spring and he brought a replica of a musket used in the war. My students thought most rifles were repeating and they could not figure how many times a soldier could shoot a musket in a minute and not get killed. Everybody touched it and it was taller than I am with the bayonet attached. (I am 5 feet) We looked at replicas of minie balls and talked about how lethal they were. These objects were a great learning tool and made students want to learn more.....and we did.
Redirect: /content/what-historical-thinking
Module Id: 689
User Id: 1514
Question 1:
I presume you mean the woman facing the camera. The dress shows me that this an upper class woman. It looks to a jacket over another garment The most important thing seems to be what is hanging from the collar. You can make out the word woman but not the other word. It is most likely from a parade scene. The other woman is dressed the same except she wears dark shoes. It had to be taken after the introduction of cars.
Question 2:
This could be women marching for temperance (WCTU) or the right to vote. It could even be a march of those opposed to war. Cars are in the picture so it could be from the 1890's to 1920's. You could connect the picture to the early suffragists, the temperance movement or even the assembly line. You could also use this to lead into the transportation revolution in America. They seem to be standing on a paved road
Redirect: /content/dress-resources
Module Id: 1075
User Id: 1514
Question 1:
It looks like a teacup and saucer from a very expensive china set. It seems to be hand painted. I certainly do not drink my morning coffee from something like that. It could be imported. Also, it probably shows what an upper class and wealthy person might use to drink tea or coffee. obviously it comes from a set (maybe a tea service) because there are other pieces of it in the background.
Question 2:
The first thing that comes to mind is the Boston Tea Party where American Patriots dressed as Indians threw tea in Boston Harbor. This incident helped lead to boycotts and the beginning of Americans becoming coffee drinkers. The picture could also be used in studying the Gilded Age and the excesses of the Rockefeller's, Morgans, and Vanderbilt's.
Redirect: /content/porcelain-resources
Module Id: 951
User Id: 1514
Question 1:
It is a letter to E.E. Alexander Esquire (could be a lawyer) addressed to Pickens, SC. it was official business and it looks like (can't really tell), it might be from Richmond, VA, the second capitol of the Confederate government.. The return address has a name I cannot read (flowing cursive) and the word auditor is under it. It could be (or not) a tax bill or something dealing with money.
Question 2:
This letter had to be between 1861 and 1865. Richmond was not made the capitol of the Confederate States until VA seceded from the Union. It was probably made the capitol to GET VA to secede. A second thought is the Confederate State's Government obviously had a postal service but it would have been faster to communicate by using the telegraph. The South was hampered by less usage of the telegraph (technology) during the war and this could have been a factor in their defeat. This item could lead to questions on the "evolution of warfare".
Redirect: /content/mail-resources
Module Id: 1021
User Id: 1514
Question 1:
It is an old can of Nescafe Coffee with some sort of milk product in it. It could be an early type of instant coffee. It may have been part of an excavation because of the damage to the can and maybe red dirt or paint.
Question 2:
If this is an early instant coffee product, then the broader theme would be how industrialization and immigration to urban areas changed the way food was prepared and eaten. This can could also represent how milk was pasteurized so it would not spoil so there was no need to own a cow. This could later lead to food production by corporations and how food companies grew powerful. I think nescafe is a product of Nestle.
Redirect: /content/coffee-resources
Module Id: 1147
User Id: 1514
Question 1:
It seems to be a microscopic picture of the small pox virus maybe from a very crude early microscope.
Question 2:
Small pox was a scourge during both the French and Indian War and the American Revolution. I think I remember the British during the French and Indian War gave blankets to Indians which had been used by small pox victims. Later George Washington gave early vaccinations to his troops. Supposedly, Washington was immune and had pock marks on his face. This could later be brought in the creation of the Salk vaccine in the 1950's or what is going on today with Covid 19
Redirect: /content/smallpox-resources
Module Id: 954
User Id: 1514
Question 1:
I would guess this is a pile of discarded tires from a factory either from a car manufacturing plant or a tire manufacturing plant prior to environmental regulations being put in place.
Question 2:
This could be connected to several broader themes in American History such as: The industrial revolution, the transportation revolution, the rise of robber barons, the move to cities, and the beginning of environmental regulations.
Redirect: /content/tire-resources
Module Id: 1108
User Id: 1514
Question 1:
This early record was awarded a 1st prize at the Portland Exposition. That might be a world's fair or something similar. The soprano on the recording was Nora Bayes with orchestra. Young America might be back up singers. The logo later on was used by RCA. It was then the Victor Talking Machine Company
Question 2:
This may be the beginning of recorded music because it won a prize in 1905. It shows a victrola on the label titled Victor so it could be a broader theme in the entertainment industry which later on in the 1920's became a major industry.
Redirect: /content/record-resources
Module Id: 1128
User Id: 1514
Question 1:
It tells us at the bottom, it is a musket ball and a measuring tape show a length of a little more than 5 inches. If I had not seen the words musket ball, I might have thought it was a rock.
Question 2:
It could possibly relate to the evolution of warfare: from stones to muskets to repeating rifles to regular bombs to nuclear weapons.
Redirect: /content/musket-ball-resources
Module Id: 955
User Id: 1514
Question 1: It is really old from probably a kitchen in a home.
Question 2: It could show the evolution of new products has accelerated
Redirect: /content/dishwasher-resources
Module Id: 1093
User Id: 1514
Question 1:
In rethinking my answer, "a way of understanding history by using objects", I would have to add "and primary sources". The 4th graders who thought the candle mold was a hotdog cooker probably came to the same conclusion that my Juniors would make in the same scenario. Why? They have never seen a candle mode. When I looked at the picture, at first I thought it was an early radiator. Of course later I realized I was wrong. Had I looked closer I might have figured it out. Using historical thinking is a way of improving instruction by letting students find answers through observation and study of objects.
Question 2:
First you must have access to some objects such as my antique "chicken catcher" or find images of them. A good example would have the students look at "Washington Crossing the Delaware" and ask them "what's wrong in this painting". Lots say he is standing up in a boat and could fall out. When I next tell them what kind of boat they used, I make them look up a that boat style and let them see standing was OK. So using objects and primary sources is a could way to encourage more historical thinking.
Redirect: /content/connections-essay-historical-thinking
Module Id: 689
User Id: 1514
Question 1:
The dress connects to the broader themes of:
1. Industrialization and the rise of factories. Maybe the dresses were not sewn by the women but bought in department stores. They may have been made in the Lowell Mills.
2. Ida B. Wells marched in a parade where she was supposed to march in the back. She wore a white dress but was an African American. This could bring up the racial inequality theme of the Jim Crow Era.
3. The picture could also bring up the theme of the early birth control movement. If women could march in parades, could they also get the freedom to use birth control (Margaret Sanger tried)
Question 2:
You could use the internet to show the list of Western states that gave women the right to vote in state elections much earlier than 1920. Alice Paul and her NAWSA members learned from the British Suffragettes. You could compare the measures both groups took to get the right to vote.
Although it takes two class periods (in a sol driven curriculum), one of the best resources is to show "Iron Jawed Angels" and give a viewing guide
Redirect: /content/dress-connections-essay
Module Id: 1075
User Id: 1514
Question 1:
Porcelain was a luxury item and when the colonial patriots boycotted tea, there obviously was no need for expensive tea cups. When talking about the boycotting of luxury items (imported items) the colonists began wearing plain homemade clothes which helped American businesses and showed their protest of "taxation without representation" which according to the authors gave them a sense of well being. Perhaps the pictured tea cup and saucer was a symbol of the British "tyranny" and helped bring on the Revolution.
Question 2:
I would want to know about the Royal Governors and how they dealt with ordinary citizens. I would like to know how much the tea destroyed in the Boston Tea Party actually cost in today's dollars. I have heard several estimates and could the British Government take these losses over a long period of time considering the costs of the French and Indian War. I would like to know whether Washington, Jefferson, Adams and Franklin actually participated in the boycotts of imported goods. Finally, I would like to hear about the one third (estimated) group of people who remained neutral during the conflict and why they remained neutral.
Redirect: /content/porcelain-connections-essay
Module Id: 951
User Id: 1514
Question 1:
The mail was a major way William Lloyd Garrison was able to send The liberator into the South. Mail was protected in the Constitution and the Postmaster General told the Post Master of Charleston SC to deliver the mail after he said it was dangerous. Mail was burned by a mob and the Postmaster more or less turned his back on this issue. Andrew Jackson was President from 1828-1836 and he was in favor of no abolitionist material being delivered but no laws were passed on Congress on the issue. The Abolitionist material was around for over 30 years. The Southern view that slavery was not a bad thing but a greater good and the Abolitionist view about the horrors of slavery could not be reconciled and it would later be a cause of the Civil War in 1861. Finally, look at the founding fathers. Of the major ones, John Adams did not own slaves. The others did not want to face the issue of abolitionism so they did not write the word slave in the Constitution. Jefferson (actually plagiarized from Locke) wrote "all men are created equal" yet only freed his own children by Sally Hemmings (His first wife's half sister)
Question 2:
I knew there had been suppression of abolitionist materials long before the Civil War began but I was not familiar with burning of mail in Charleston in the 1830's. I assumed the impetus for secession was later in the 1850's but you can see how the Southern viewpoint changes early. With slavery seen as a greater good and abolitionist material was considered an attack on southern life, there was very little hope of compromise. Looking at the drawing of the Happy slaves in the materials and the words of the Liberator would be an excellent way to show students the probability of stopping the Civil War was not very good.
Redirect: /content/mail-connections-essay
Module Id: 1021
User Id: 1514
Question 1:
Obviously, I was on the right track about instant coffee but I never really thought about the preparation of food for the soldiers who were sent to Europe and Asia. The film showing soldiers sweating was shown to see how the army studied their nutrition needs in hot climates and conversely in cold climates. This can could also show how canned foods became a staple after World War II because the war ended so quickly by the dropping of the Atomic Bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. During WWII, the government urged women to grow their own food as patriotic and then can it. Boom! The bombs dropped and corporations needed for consumers mostly women to accept processed foods. The story of the cake mix is the perfect example. Women did not accept it until it required an egg added.
Question 2:
We are often taught that after World War II, Rosie the Riveter and working women in war production went home and produced the Baby Boom generation. That is partially true but that theory is limited because the number of women who went into the workplace increased over time. By the 60's and the birth of the women's movement, the ideal woman changed. "The Total Woman" stopped being the norm and the working woman became the "new normal". Advertising changed to appeal to the new working class woman and foods mirror that change. Campbell's Soup, boxed or frozen dinners, and fast food (such as McDonalds) became acceptable and the norm. That we have Grub Hub in Wise, VA shows the ever evolving role of women
Redirect: /content/coffee-connections-essay
Module Id: 1147
User Id: 1514
Question 1:
In the articles we read on this subject one learns about the effects of smallpox on people who had no immunity such as Native Americans and young soldiers who had not been exposed to it. The small pox epidemics helped weaken Indian tribes and this helped lead to their defeat. Another effect of smallpox was on trade or transatlantic commerce. The virus was brought over on trading ships and some ports had to shut down (quarantine) to stop its spread such as in Charleston in the 18th century. Trade was vital to both England and the colonies and if trade was interrupted, it had a trickle down effect on the colonial economies
Question 2:
One benefit would be to show how leaders dealt with diseases. You could show how Washington's greatest feat was using inoculations during the Revolutionary War. A drawback would be teaching this to anti-vaccine students who refuse to get the Covid shot.
Redirect: /content/connections-essay-smallpox
Module Id: 954
User Id: 1514
Question 1:
Obviously, I was on the wrong track when I saw the first picture. This is about how the U.S. won World War II after Pearl Harbor in 1941. Roosevelt had pledged not to send our boys over there. We became the arsenal of democracy arming our troops. The nation had to deal with shortages. The articles said the U.S. did not develop synthetic rubber until late in the War. Rationing had to take place. No cars were produced during the war so car plants could make tanks, jeeps etc. It became patriotic to follow the "rules" by not using cars for vacations etc. Rationing effected all Americans. Rubber and gasoline were very limited. Women were also encouraged to enter the work force to take the jobs of 16 million soldiers. Later this would help lead to the women's movement. In 4 years, the war was won and both Germany and Japan were defeated. The U.S. went into a new boom while England and other countries were far behind. There was still rationing in England during the 1950's. What the country did in World War II would lead to the growth of a big military industrial economy which helped lead us into the Cold War.
Question 2:
Although propaganda posters were with us in World War I, it became more prominent in World War II. I would first ask students to define propaganda and then show various examples of it. In this module there are classic examples such as the woman carrying her groceries rather than driving with soldiers in the background and the pretty blonde lady taking the pledge not to use the black market but to use her ration book. These posters could lead to discussions on the role of women in the war and how they were made to feel important. You could ask the question, "Is propaganda still with us today" and give examples of anti-smoking campaigns which end with "You can quit....we can help" and of course the covid 19 campaigns designed to make people get vaccinated. Since posters are not used very much today, this could lead to a discussion on how the government does influence/control advertising. The Classic example is cigarette/Joe Camel ads which are no longer shown on TV. Finally, you could contrast the posters used in World War I with those used in World War II.
Redirect: /content/tire-connections-essay
Module Id: 1108
User Id: 1514
Question 1:
When I saw the record, it never occurred to me that the question would be about immigration. When I listened to Nora Bayes sing, she made jokes about the various immigrant groups from Ireland, Germany, other European countries. The other pictures show how immigrants were treated. The Jamaican women identified themselves as West Indians but at Ellis Island the word black was written over their names. This showed prejudice and it would later show up in the anti immigration acts of the 1920's. I found it interesting that most of the West Indian people did not want to be US Citizens. They wanted to come to America, make money, and go back to where they lived. In addition, they were literate and that was not typical for immigrants of this era.
Question 2:
I live in an area that was founded on coal mines and miners. Some areas were called "hunky towns" to note where Hungarian immigrants lived. A great source to use would be tax rolls of various locations in southwest VA. They would show the names of immigrants and would give students a better view of the national origins of the groups. Early newspapers which are often online today would be another resource for students to study. Over time, the immigrants assimilated into communities. Finally, I would use a letter I own written to a man in Coeburn from Switzerland asking repayment of a debt. The letter was in French but I had it translated. The students would probably find that unusual.
Redirect: /content/record-connections-essay
Module Id: 1128
User Id: 1514
Question 1:
One thing the musket ball did was determine the way armies fought battles. I always thought that the minutemen who fought in the Battles of Lexington and Concord were so much smarter than the soldiers that stood in lines shoulder to shoulder. Now I find out that our best army was the Continental Army which was trained essentially the same way as the Red Coat Army. Repeating rifles do not come into play until late in the Civil War and Lee turned them down because of the expense. Washington brought in Von Steuben to train his armies in the European method and in the various sources I read, the best soldiers were disciplined automatons who were very fearful of their own commanders. Washington in his farewell address warned of entangling alliances and also standing armies. The new Americans took to heart these warnings. They remembered the Boston Massacre where British troops opened fire on patriots and they did not trust big armies for years to come.
Question 2:
Since the Revolutionary War was over in 1783, there were only seventeen years until the 19th Century began. This would be the era of the Articles of Confederation and the writing of the Constitution plus George Washington's presidency. Obviously, the Articles of Confederation and its government were too weak and they feared another George III with the big army at his command. It would be interesting to read documents with accounts of Shays' Rebellion and conversely to accounts of the Whiskey Rebellion. In one, troops from Massachusetts had to put it down and in the other, troops led by Washington had to lead a large army to put down the rebellion. In both cases, there was no large standing army so a force had to be called together. Although Washington was an iconic war hero, even he was against big armies in peace time. This general feeling lasted into the 20th Century and World War II>
Redirect: /content/musket-ball-connections-essay
Module Id: 955
User Id: 1514
Question 1:
One thing the musket ball did was determine the way armies fought battles. I always thought that the minutemen who fought in the Battles of Lexington and Concord were so much smarter than the soldiers that stood in lines shoulder to shoulder. Now I find out that our best army was the Continental Army which was trained essentially the same way as the Red Coat Army. Repeating rifles do not come into play until late in the Civil War and Lee turned them down because of the expense. Washington brought in Von Steuben to train his armies in the European method and in the various sources I read, the best soldiers were disciplined automatons who were very fearful of their own commanders. Washington in his farewell address warned of entangling alliances and also standing armies. The new Americans took to heart these warnings. They remembered the Boston Massacre where British troops opened fire on patriots and they did not trust big armies for years to come.
Question 2:
Since the Revolutionary War was over in 1783, there were only seventeen years until the 19th Century began. This would be the era of the Articles of Confederation and the writing of the Constitution plus George Washington's presidency. Obviously, the Articles of Confederation and its government were too weak and they feared another George III with the big army at his command. It would be interesting to read documents with accounts of Shays' Rebellion and conversely to accounts of the Whiskey Rebellion. In one, troops from Massachusetts had to put it down and in the other, troops led by Washington had to lead a large army to put down the rebellion. In both cases, there was no large standing army so a force had to be called together. Although Washington was an iconic war hero, even he was against big armies in peace time. This general feeling lasted into the 20th Century and World War II>
Redirect: /content/musket-ball-connections-essay
Module Id: 955
User Id: 1514
Title: Engaging Students Using More Everyday Objects
Grade Level: High
Short Answer:
As I watched all the videos, I was amazed how many things I have used that were in the videos. Washington Crossing the Delaware, The Boston Massacre, Runaway Slave letters from UVA are just a few I use. I took this course to get more ideas on things I can use to make History more interesting. I plan the first week of school to take some items that I own (old german iron, a daguerreotype of some unknown person, and a letter from a very distant relative from Switzerland) After they look at them and touch them, I will ask them to tell me from what they have seen, what kind of people settled far Southwest VA.
Redirect: /content/analyzing-objects-wrap
Module Id: 689
User Id: 1514
Title: What a Dress Can Tell You
Grade Level: High
Short Answer:
One of the things that caught my attention in this module was the dress of the American Suffragists. (No, British women were Suffragettes and Americans were called Suffragists) The photos of the ladies in all white were an early form of propaganda. Even though they were marching, their dresses were all white which portrayed them as pure and genteel. When school reconvenes in August I happen to own a May 8, 1927 "Rotogravure Picture Section" of the New York Times. I plan to use it several times because one of the many pictures shows "Girls of the Junior Class" a picture showing girls from St. Vincent's Academy after hosting a Bridge Party for their parents and teachers. It will likely draw interesting comments. By the way as a side note: I just got back from playing Duplicate Bridge in Raleigh.
Redirect: /content/dress-wrap
Module Id: 1075
User Id: 1514
Title: Was the Civil War Inevitable? Looking at Evidence.
Grade Level: High
Short Answer:
I would ask students, "Could the Civil War have been avoided?" I would show them the advertisement showing the sale of the men, women, and children ad and then tell them why slave prices soared after 1807 (end of the slave trade). Second I would show the graphic of the happy and well taken care of slaves (the happy slave theory) and then I would show them sections from the Liberator. I would show them the list of the Presidents that owned or were from families that owned slaves. The last was U.S. Grant. Finally, I would ask how the U.S. Mail affectedly of this controversy.
Redirect: /content/mail-wrap
Module Id: 1021
User Id: 1514
Title: Nobody Cooks Like THAT Anymore...or do they??????
Grade Level: High
Short Answer:
This will be fun. I will put on one of my late mother's aprons and take into class loaves of homemade Sour Dough Bread for my U.S. History classes. (yes, I will give the students a small bite if Covid restrictions are not in place) In addition, I will have a selection of antique implements such as my antique "chicken catcher" and talk about when, how, and why food preparation changed so drastically due to World War II and advertising. The final items I will show will be a family cookbook (called Any Ninny Can Cook) I wrote with the help of my sisters and a real Ration Card from World War II. Hopefully, these items will spark interest.
Redirect: /content/coffee-wrap
Module Id: 1147
User Id: 1514
Title: George Washington's Greatest Achievement?
Grade Level: High
Short Answer:
Students could do a web quest on Washington's achievements and share their results in class It is doubtful any of the students would use inoculation of troops (as in the article we just read). Ask them to look up about Washington inoculating his troops that saved lives and perhaps brought on victory in the American Revolution.
Redirect: /content/smallpox-wrap
Module Id: 954
User Id: 1514
Title: Can the U.S. Government take awake your energy drinks? Yes or No!
Grade Level: High
Short Answer:
After posing the question, I would take a vote. (yes or no) Then I would show them a ration book from World War II. I happen to own one that belonged to my parents. (I am much older than most of your students) Photo-copies are available and students could see what products were rationed. The second question could be "Can the U.S. Government ban or take away energy drinks? (They do cause elevated heart rates with overuse.) After that discussion, the final question would be "If the government rationed goods in World War II, could they do it again.
Redirect: /content/tire-wrap
Module Id: 1108
User Id: 1514
Title: What Immigrants brought to America that affects you today!
Grade Level: High
Short Answer:
I would bring items for them to look at such as a pizza box, a Chinese takeout carton, a menu from Taco Bell, a bottle of French perfume, a photo of silent film star Rudolph Valentino, a pair of tennis shoes, and a variety of other items. I would divide the students into groups and let them look and touch the items. Finally, I would have them decide how immigrants have changed the way they live in America.
Redirect: /content/record-wrap
Module Id: 1128
User Id: 1514
Title: If Muskets and the Revolutionary War: Would you have fought?????
Grade Level: High
Short Answer:
To engage the students, I would bring to class a a history buff that has replicas of muskets from the Revolutionary War and into the Civil War. (Yes, there is one in Wise County) The gentleman would explain to students the difficulties of fighting during the Revolution and how the very best soldiers could reload a musket at the very best four times in a minute. After looking at the display, I would ask them to compare then and now and would they have fought.
Redirect: /content/musket-ball-wrap
Module Id: 955
User Id: 1514