Analyzing Objects

Porcelain

Musket Ball

Smallpox

Nail

Reaper

Shirtwaist

Transistor

Coffee

Record

Tire

Dishwasher

Dress

Stereograph

Stone

Mail

Shoe

Question 1:
Historical thinking is analyzing history through the context of the time period. By using primary documents and artifacts rather than simply reading a summation of history through the lens of an author of a textbook, students learn to become historical thinkers. Historical thinking helps us to view history through the eyes of those who experienced it.
Question 2:
Using historical objects transforms history into something tangible. Invariably historical objects create curiosity. Students will use their own background knowledge and experiences to envision how a particular object was utilized in another time period. Then they begin to view history as the story and experiences of people. Historical objects help students to bridge the gap between their own lives and those who lived in previous time periods.
Redirect: /content/what-historical-thinking
Module Id: 689
User Id: 1418
Question 1:
These shoes appear to be a pair of women's shoes possibly from the 1920's or 30's. They are leather with hand stitching. These shoes are very worn but but have held up well to apparently a lot of wear.
Question 2:
I suspect these shoes belonged to a woman from the 1920's or 30's. Maybe they are representative of a woman suffragist or a woman who experienced the hard times during the Great Depression years.
Redirect: /content/shoe-resources
Module Id: 1002
User Id: 1418
Question 1:
This appears to be a coffee tin possibly from the early 1900's. The tin is rusted so it was likely before the invention of a metal alloy that resisted rusting. The company name "Nescafe" is a name associated with coffee products even today. The company apparently originated in New York. The coffee grounds have added ingredients most likely to prevent clumping or used as a preservative.
Question 2:
Prior to the availability of ground coffee being sold in individual tins, most people ground their own coffee with a hand grinder. Around the turn of the century when more and more products were being mass produced, people purchased canned goods from general stores or from mail order companies. This reflected a shift from families relying predominantly on subsistence farming to people enjoying the convenience of the industrial age. These modern conveniences allowed food products to have a longer shelf life and to be more easily transported.
Redirect: /content/coffee-resources
Module Id: 1147
User Id: 1418
Question 1:
These appear to be different types of nails. Modern nails are galvanized to prevent them from rusting. These nails also appear to be hand-made rather than factory made. They probably have different uses as they have different shapes and various types of heads on the nails. Possibly some of these may have been used to shoe horses.
Question 2:
The use of these types of nails might connect to the time period in history when most structures were made of wood prior to the invention of steel. These nails would have been made of iron and would have been made by a blacksmith. These nails place us in a time period prior to industrialization.
Redirect: /content/nail-resources
Module Id: 953
User Id: 1418
Question 1:
This object appears to be a grave stone marker. It appears to be simply a large flat faced stone or a hand chiseled stone. The marker does not appear to be in a typical graveyard. It's very hard to determine the words on the stone. I can clearly see the letters "ON' on the right side of the stone. Possibly the date in the bottom right corner is 1790.
Question 2:
Grave stone markers are an important part of history. As reminders of those who have preceded us in time, gravestones and their locations give us clues about the past. As the final page of a person's story in time, the gravestone is a reminder to us, the living, to not forget those who were here before us. Their experiences are linked to ours in time. The gravestone markers themselves can sometimes indicate clues about a person's life such as the time period the person lived, whether the person was a war veteran, how old the person was when he/she died, and sometimes if the person was married. Elaborate markers in well maintained cemeteries may tell us that the person had wealth or some type of significance. A simple stone marker with no writing in the forest on the side of a mountain may indicate the person died very early in history, possibly may have lived without great wealth, or may have died tragically or unexpectedly. Information on gravestones can be used to further our investigation as that information can be used to research birth/death records, newspapers, land deeds etc. Although gravestones were a finality for those were preceded us, they can often be the beginning of a journey into the past.
Redirect: /content/stone-resources
Module Id: 1039
User Id: 1418
Question 1:
This photo of a dishwasher is very interesting because the dishwasher, which would have been modern household luxury, is in a photo with some type of oil lantern situated on the counter. The sink is also made of stainless steel. I would guess based on the cabinetry and tiled wall that this photo was possibly taking in the 1950's.
Question 2:
This object may reflect a period when many modern conveniences were invented that greatly decreased the amount of time women spent on daily household chores. Electric irons, toasters, vacuum cleaners, and washing machines are just a few of the new modern conveniences which allowed women more time to engage in other activities. These new time saving appliances influenced the changing roles of women.
Redirect: /content/dishwasher-resources
Module Id: 1093
User Id: 1418
Question 1:
The dress this lady is wearing is the type of dress commonly worn by women suffragists. She has a sash pinned to the dress that appears to say "woman suffragist". Today the color of white is a symbolic color worn by those who support women's rights issues.
Question 2:
The dress is representative of the many women who advocated for the right to vote and gained that right by 1920 as a result of the 19th amendment. The movement began in 1848 in Seneca Falls, New York. Suffragist leaders such Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony organized the movement and were later followed by leaders such as Carrie Cat Chapman, Lucy Burns and Alice Paul.
Redirect: /content/dress-resources
Module Id: 1075
User Id: 1418
Question 1:
This is a very ornate tea cup and saucer. It appears to be a part of a collection of matching dinnerware. It is likely hand-made. Possibly this cup and saucer date back to the Revolutionary Period due to the fact that the blue color was a characteristic of the period. Having this type of gold trimmed dinnerware could possibly indicate that the person who possessed it was someone of importance.
Question 2:
When one thinks of porcelain, often it is associated with China. Could this teacup and saucer be imported from China? If so, maybe it is related to the opening up of trade with China with the Open Door Policy which would relate to the broader theme of American imperialism.
Redirect: /content/porcelain-resources
Module Id: 951
User Id: 1418
Question 1:
Historical thinking is analyzing sources, considering multiple perspectives, addressing complex issues and developing interpretations about the past. Through historical thinking we form an hypothesis, ask questions and investigate through historical context.
Question 2:
By using historical objects and utilizing methods like "See - Think- Wonder", students develop the skills to become historical thinkers. By introducing historical objects to lessons, teachers can help students to think more critically about history. For example, by using the "Mystery Object Exercise" students engage in asking questions, forming a hypothesis, and drawing conclusions.
Redirect: /content/connections-essay-historical-thinking
Module Id: 689
User Id: 1418
Question 1:
In a broader sense, the shoes represent America's struggle to remain one nation and to redefine the roles between states and the national government. This plain, ordinary but personal item demonstrates how all Americans were touch by the Civil War. Shoes were a necessity for soldiers on both sides. However, neither side had the capacity to mass produce shoes. This simple item will require the federal government to assume a larger role in the economy and people's lives in order to meet the demand. This increased role of the federal government will be used in many ways (the draft, control over railroads and telegraph lines and other industries) in order for the North to win the war and ultimately keep the nation together.
Question 2:
During the Civil War Lincoln took control of the telegraph lines to be able to communicate faster and more effectively with military leaders. By examining a telegraph message sent from Lincoln to a general during the war, students can analyze how this technology allowed for the government to increase its engagement with troops a well as communicate with citizens. Another example of a primary source that changed the relationship between government and its citizens is photographs. The Civil War was the first war in which photography was used to inform people about the horrors of the battlefield. These photos influenced public opinion of the war. As news and photographs about the war reached citizens, the government became more accountable than ever for decisions made in a time of war. From this point forward, the government would have to take increased consideration for public opinion about future wars.
Redirect: /content/shoe-connections-essay
Module Id: 1002
User Id: 1418
Question 1:
Instant coffee is a reflection of how the modernization of canned and processed food products was born out of necessity and not simply convenience. In order to feed troops fighting in wars in other parts of the world, food processing and nutrition was examined from a scientific perspective. America's involvement in global wars required the army to develop ways in which nutritious food could be easily transported and accessible to soldiers on the battlefield. The idea of instant coffee is an example of the type of ration a soldier might have, along with processed eggs whites, processed canned meat and even chewing gum! After WWII, the abundance of these rations led to a challenge for companies to shift their market to the general public. This transition mirrored the changes taking place in society as Americans embraced scientific knowledge and modern conveniences while trying to hold on to traditional values.
Question 2:
New modern conveniences in the household challenged the traditional roles of women in home. As the primary caregivers and home managers, women's lives were consumed with cooking, cleaning, and managing the affairs of the household. Food preparation itself dominated much of their time out of the day. These newly developed canned products, mixes, etc. were originally viewed as "shortcuts" for less industrious women. Companies had to change the mindset of America in order win over their market target - women. As these products became more widely accepted, women expanded their roles into other areas of society such as working outside the home. These modern conveniences allowed women to embrace new careers and engage in social groups while still being able to provide nutritious meals to their families.
Redirect: /content/coffee-connections-essay
Module Id: 1147
User Id: 1418
Question 1:
The era of mass produced nails directly reflects with the types of housing Americans had. For example, before mass-produced nails, nails were hand-made by a blacksmith and very expensive. So people designed houses that required fewer nails such as brick and mortar, log, and post and beam. Several of these building methods required skilled craftsmen and created other drawbacks. The introduction of a mass-produced nail made building houses less expensive. Fewer skilled craftsmen were need as boards could be ordered pre-cut. This transition in construction led to what we know of today as the modern framed house structure which was originally called a "balloon frame". In essence, the simple nail being mass-produced is a symbol of the country's transition away from products produced by skilled artisans and cottage industries to an abundance of products being mass-produced for a rapidly expanding nation.
Question 2:
When we think of westward expansion in the 1820's and 1830's, we think about the Americans conquering the wilderness and setting up homesteads beyond the Appalachian Mountains.
Redirect: /content/nail-connections-essay
Module Id: 953
User Id: 1418
Question 1:
The era of mass produced nails directly reflects with the types of housing Americans had. For example, before mass-produced nails, nails were hand-made by a blacksmith and very expensive. So people designed houses that required fewer nails such as brick and mortar, log, and post and beam. Several of these building methods required skilled craftsmen and created other drawbacks. The introduction of a mass-produced nail made building houses less expensive. Fewer skilled craftsmen were need as boards could be ordered pre-cut. This transition in construction led to what we know of today as the modern framed house structure which was originally called a "balloon frame". In essence, the simple nail being mass-produced is a symbol of the country's transition away from products produced by skilled artisans and cottage industries to an abundance of products being mass-produced for a rapidly expanding nation.
Question 2:
When we think of westward expansion in the 1820's and 1830's, we think about the Americans conquering the wilderness and setting up homesteads beyond the Appalachian Mountains. The image that comes to mind is the log cabin house. I never considered the log cabin being the home of the frontier because of the lack of or high cost of nails. I always just considered it from the perspective of the abundance of trees. It makes perfect sense that these settlers needed inexpensive homes that did not require nails or a skilled craftsman to build. As I have often heard, "necessity is the mother of invention"!
Redirect: /content/nail-connections-essay
Module Id: 953
User Id: 1418
Question 1:
The boundary marker represents many changes taking place within the new nation of the United States of America. One of the broader themes the marker addresses is the political divide created by the evolution of the first political parties. The location of the new nation's capital was the result of strategic bargaining between leaders of the Federalist and Democratic-Republican parties. It's location was meant to ease the Democratic-Republicans' fears of a national government dominated by the interest of northern bankers and businessmen. In exchange for establishing the seat of government closer to the south and specifically at the doorstep of Virginia - arguably the most powerful southern state - the Democratic -Republicans conceded on the Federalists' desire to create a new national bank. At the root of the political division in the country was another broader theme -its growth into two distinct regions - North and South. Each region had different economic, political, and social characteristics that were sometimes at odds with each other. Possibly this new capital city could offer a forum for compromise. Finally, in an era of strong state power, the creation of the new capital city in a district that was an entity of itself and not subject to the direct influence of one particular state, Washington, D.C. was a distinct representation of the country's idea of federalism. This capital city was the seat of the national government. In this time period, the new national government established by the Constitution was in the midst of redefining itself after the debacle of the Articles of Confederation. Although this capital city was initially designed to create unity and to bind two distinct regions together, it would be a the heart of the greatest test of federalism in our history - the Civil War.
Question 2:
Boundaries are essentially barriers. Whether those "barriers" are designed to keep something together or to prevent something from coming in is important. The changing of boundaries often reflects large influential change in society. Boundaries were essential during the creation of the United States. Boundaries established what land could be colonized and the specific formation of the thirteen colonies - each established for unique reasons and by specific groups. These boundaries also reflect who holds power and where. As the nation's boundaries expanded, it reflected our growth of power in world. These boundaries are also a reflection of our ideas about democracy and our attempt to keep out those ideas which contradict it. In our history, boundaries have also demonstrated our internal struggle with the institution of slavery. Attempts to avoid the Civil War included adhering to laws subject to boundaries between the North and South, the Missouri Compromise and other Pre-Civil War compromises. In the post Civil War era, the nation struggled with a century of discriminatory laws which clearly established geographical and social boundaries between groups of people. As America became a world power, it expanded its boundaries and sphere of influence in other parts of the world. During WWI, WWII and the Cold War era, the adhering to geographic boundaries was important to protect ourselves and other nations from the expansion of tyranny and the infiltration of fascism and communism. Throughout history boundaries have defined us and helped to explain our experiences.
Redirect: /content/stone-connections-essay
Module Id: 1039
User Id: 1418
Question 1:
This modern household convenience has an underlying Cold War significance. As American industries shifted from war to peace time production, American consumerism drove the demand for modern conveniences such as dish washers, automobiles, and washing machines. As a result, the American standard of living increased and capitalism flourished demonstrating the dominance of our economic system at the height of an era of competition between the U.S. and the Soviet Union. This product represents more than simply an invention that reduces the amount of time women spent on the daunting task of washing dishes. The product, like the moon landing, is an example of the superiority of American ingenuity. The subtle message is that our capitalism and democracy is better than communism. We will out invent you, out spend you, and prevail over communism from dishwashers to Reagan's SDI missile defense system.
Question 2:
I did not realize that the Cold War competition included such everyday items as the dishwasher. When I think about the Cold War, I think about nuclear missiles, the race to the moon, duck and cover drills - not a dishwasher! How interesting that American foreign policy had infiltrated American households to that extent.
Redirect: /content/dishwasher-connections-essay
Module Id: 1093
User Id: 1418
Question 1:
The simple white dress was symbolic of the simplicity of the cause. Women were citizens and thus simply should have the right to vote. As the roles of women were changing as a result of technology and the responsibilities they undertook as a result of WWI, women had to convince society that they could continue to be the kinder, gentler, pure maternal figures while exercising their political rights as citizens. The dress is also a symbol of purity. Ironically, the dress itself was likely made in a sewing factory which on one hand freed women from hand-sewing the family's clothing, but on the other bound women to the same stereotypical roles. The long white dress, like women themselves of the time period, represents an attempt at some level to embody traditional values, to continue to be viewed as the "purer" of the two sexes, but also be a symbol of strength for a higher purpose.
Question 2:
Secondary sources such as suffragist newspapers, diaries, or letters would provide more insight into the movement as well as the private struggles of the suffragists themselves. Some woman would not openly support the movement, but privately hoped for its success. As woman gained more time to involve themselves in political activities supporting the movement, they used banners, wrote speeches, and other documents to convince the world of their ability to make wise decisions as voters. These documents would allow us to see women as intellectuals not just housewives and mothers.
Redirect: /content/dress-connections-essay
Module Id: 1075
User Id: 1418
Question 1:
This Revolutionary Era porcelain is a symbol of the connection between Britain and her American colonies. At first this luxury item demonstrated desired cultural ties to the mother country. It represented the broader theme of mercantilism in which the colonies were reliant on Britain for goods that they themselves could not manufacture. In a broader sense, the porcelain is reflective of the transition of thirteen separate colonies controlled by an imperial power, to thirteen colonies redefining themselves, eventually as an independent nation. Items like porcelain were taxed heavily by the Townshend Acts. Colonists were willing to boycott this luxury item as a symbol of rebellion against the violation of their English right of representation in Parliament. As colonists boycotted English goods, they began to form their own identity by replacing items such as clothing, tea, and glassware with American made substitutes. The much desired porcelain representing the cultural and economic ties to Britain became a symbol of a tyrannical government which came to be rejected by the colonists.
Question 2:
To better understand the causes of the American Revolution, it would be interesting to see the level of taxation prior to the French and Indian War compared to the increase of taxes after that war. Americans were used to paying indirect taxes and accepted the level of control Britain had over the colonies prior to that point. I often wonder if American independence was inevitable, but simply accelerated by the increase in taxes and tighter control by Britain. In other words, I wonder if colonists were motivated to declare independence based upon a series of events, or were they already heading towards an irrevocable separation. One primary document that may provide some incite on this topic is Thomas Paine's "Common Sense".
Redirect: /content/porcelain-connections-essay
Module Id: 951
User Id: 1418
Title: East Rockingham High School
Grade Level: High
Short Answer:
In my U.S. History class there are many opportunities for me to incorporate historical thinking with my students. By introducing artifacts from particular time periods, I could use strategies such as "see-think-wonder" to help students to connect to the time period. To encourage students to view history from multiple perspectives, I could require them to analyze primary documents conveying different perspectives of a controversial event in history. In doing so, I would teach students how to view the sources in their larger historical context, to consider the intentions of the respective authors, and to compare and contrast the sources to better understand the complexity of history. I also think the "Mystery Object Exercise" is an excellent way to encourage students to think critically about history. This strategy requires students to develop a hypothesis, investigate their theory, and ultimately draw conclusions based upon their knowledge of the time period. In addition, these strategies encourage dialog between students as they explore various interpretations about historical objects and other types of primary sources.
Redirect: /content/analyzing-objects-wrap
Module Id: 689
User Id: 1418
Title: Photography of the Civil War
Grade Level: High
Short Answer:
I would begin by explaining to students about how the introduction of photography impacted people's perception of the Civil War. For the first time, people were able to see the realities of war captured in photographs. I would have students examine several photos from the Civil War era. I would ask students to describe how these photos would have impacted different people's perception of the war. They would need to consider how the same image may impact people in different ways considering their role (soldier, general, folks back home, a nurse etc) during the time period.
Redirect: /content/shoe-wrap
Module Id: 1002
User Id: 1418
Title: From Sears and Roebuck to Amazon
Grade Level: High
Short Answer:
I have a reproduction copy of a 1908 Sears and Roebuck catalog. One could order most anything from a new dress to one's own tombstone. I have students examine the catalog and determine how the mail order catalog helped to transition America into a consumer based society. Students enjoy looking at all the products available, the prices of the time period, and comparing the experience of those at the turn of the century to Amazon shoppers of today. After completing the lesson on instant coffee, I could have students examine how our method of shopping on Amazon today reflects changes in our society.
Redirect: /content/coffee-wrap
Module Id: 1147
User Id: 1418
Title: Railroads and Time Zones
Grade Level: High
Short Answer:
Students are always surprised by the fact that our country's time zones were created as a result of the transcontinental railroad. In a similar type of activity, I would present students with a picture of a railroad track and ask them to brainstorm the many ways railroads impacted people's lives. Students will invariably come up with some of the obvious impacts, but rarely are they aware of the creation of time zones. I would then give students a hint by having them examine railroad departure and arrival times in the late 1800's with some guided questions to get them thinking about the concept of time and why time zones were needed.
Redirect: /content/nail-wrap
Module Id: 953
User Id: 1418
Title: Federalism - Boundaries between State and National Government in a National Pandemic
Grade Level: High
Short Answer:
In the midst of this global pandemic, I cannot help but to think about boundaries -whether they be between countries, states, or simply political boundaries within our own federal system of government. In U.S. History students begin to understand the complex American idea of federalism and then expand upon a more in depth understanding of that concept in U.S. Government. This is a lesson I would implement in a U.S. Government class. First I would explain to students why the idea of federalism was so important to the founding fathers and how the Constitution demonstrates the idea of federalism. I would then ask students to design a Venn diagram that reflects the "boundaries" between national and state power as well as those concurrent powers (or more porous boundaries) which they share. Then I would have students create another Venn diagram specific to the Coronvirus pandemic which demonstrates the ways in which each level of government has responded to the pandemic within its sphere of power as well as examples of concurrent or shared responses. Then I would have students discuss ways in which our boundaries established by the idea of federalism have both helped and hindered our country's response to the pandemic.
Redirect: /content/stone-wrap
Module Id: 1039
User Id: 1418
Title: From Dishwashers to Nuclear Weapons
Grade Level: High
Short Answer:
I would show students a series of Cold War Era pictures and include pictures of modern conveniences such as the dishwasher that were produced after WWII. I would ask students to choose the pictures that were related to the Cold War. Many students will invariably not select a dishwasher and possibly even poke fun at the idea of it being included in the selection of photos. Then I would tell the students that all pictures were relevant to the Cold War and challenge them with the task of figuring out why.
Redirect: /content/dishwasher-wrap
Module Id: 1093
User Id: 1418
Title: Clothing Styles a Representation of History
Grade Level: High
Short Answer:
I would have students analyze clothing styles from various time periods and hypothesize as to why people wore those particular styles. For example, why did colonial men wear stockings and ruffles, why did women of the 1920's wear fringes on their short dress, or why did 19th century women wear corsets? Students would need to evaluate the social issues of the time periods as well as the historical events which may have contributed to the styles.
Redirect: /content/dress-wrap
Module Id: 1075
User Id: 1418
Title: American Fashion
Grade Level: High
Short Answer:
The module mentioned how the colonists went as far as to design their own clothing as a result of the British boycott. It would be interesting to have students compare and contrast the pre-Revolutionary clothing styles with the styles created during and after the Revolutionary Period. Students could examine pictures representative of the respective time periods and analyze why such changes in American clothing may have been made.
Redirect: /content/porcelain-wrap
Module Id: 951
User Id: 1418